Reviewer
Reviewers evaluate manuscripts submitted to the journal and provide recommendations to editors. OJS supports anonymous (single-blind), double-blind, and open peer review.
Role scope
Reviewers only see the manuscript(s) assigned to them for review. They cannot access other submissions, editorial correspondence, or journal settings.
Responsibilities
| Task | Description |
|---|---|
| Review Invitation | Accept or decline review requests |
| Manuscript Access | Download and read the assigned manuscript |
| Review Form | Complete the editor-defined review questionnaire |
| Recommendation | Submit a recommendation (accept, revise, decline) |
| Comments | Provide comments for the editor and/or author |
| File Upload | Upload annotated manuscripts or supplementary files |
| Deadlines | Complete reviews by the set deadline |
Sections in This Guide
- Accepting or Declining an Invitation — how to respond to a review request
- Accessing the Manuscript — downloading submission files and metadata
- Completing the Review Form — step-by-step review submission
- Review Guidelines — general best practices for peer review
- Managing Your Reviewer Profile — updating interests, availability, and contact details
Receiving a Review Request
When assigned a submission, you will receive an email with:
- A link to the submission in OJS
- The review deadline
- Instructions from the editor
You can also see pending review requests by logging in and going to:
User Menu → Dashboard → My Queue
Review Types in OJS 3.5+
| Type | Author sees reviewer? | Reviewer sees author? |
|---|---|---|
| Double-blind | No | No |
| Single-blind (anonymous) | No | Yes |
| Open | Yes | Yes |
The review type is set per section by the Journal Manager.
Further Reading
- Learning OJS – Reviewing — Reviewer role walkthrough
- COPE Peer Review Guidelines — Ethical peer review standards
- Web of Science Reviewer Recognition — Track your peer review contributions
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions for Reviewers: